CU Student’s Assocation

CUSA General Elections

February 10 & 11

More to come…

January Council Meeting – Recap

- CUSA has started a fundraising campaign to raise money for help in the relief fund to Haiti. Look for volunteers in the atrium, a talent show, and a garage sale. You can also make donations in the CUSA office.

- The CUSA General Elections will be February 10 & 11. If you want to run, nomination period starts Monday, January 25th, 2010. For more information visit CUSA’s election website.

- Councillors elected an Electoral Board. Sitting on the important decision-making body that will help monitor the CUSA Elections are Heather Murley, James Witherspoon, and Alexandria DiBellonia.

OTHER MOTIONS *Find the original motion below

- Council adopted the first motion to ban audio-visual material in the election. I spoke in favour of the motion, believing it would give some students with equipment and the know-how with an unfair advantage.

- We also voted in favour of the motion to give equal consequence to the “No” committee in an election. This will prevent one side taking advantage of opposing a ballot question.

- The third motion to consolidate the electoral code did not get a seconder, and was thrown out.

- The final motion, to put important announcements on the CUSA website, was referred to the Constitution and Policy committee.

That was all. The election’s on its way… so expect a wild race.

Motion to Ban Audio/Video Campaign Materials

PRESENTATION SUMMARY:

Whereas audio/visual campaigning was prohibited in the 2009 Elections because of it was deemed by both the Chief Electoral Officer and the Electoral Board to be unfair;
Whereas it is incredibly difficult, if not impossible, to judge the “fair market value” of video production, giving candidates with access to professional audio/visual equipment an unfair advantage;
Whereas it is impossible for the Chief Electoral Officer to ensure the fair use, distribution and content of sites such as You Tube;

INFORMATION TRANSFER

Be it resolved that the following section be added to the Consolidated Electoral Code Policy:
12.0 Campaigning
12.22 “The use of Audio/Video campaign material is not permitted. This includes but is not limited to Radio Advertisements, Youtube videos etc

MOVED: Nick Curtis         SECONDED: Abdirahman Hussein

Motion to Amend Electoral Code Section 15

PRESENTATION SUMMARY:

Whereas there are serious consequences for a YES Committee that deals with a requested levy such as the with-holding of up to ten (10) percent of the requested levy;
Whereas the most serious consequence for a YES Committee that deals with a requested levy is “…the with-holding of one hundred (100) percent of the requested levy, immediate disqualification and loss of re-imbursement of funds spent on campaigning;
Whereas all other referenda committees, including any NO Committee that deal with a requested levy, are subject to only the loss of any possible re-imbursement;
Whereas there is no incentive for a NO Committee to ensure a fair vote other than losing money spent;
INFORMATION TRANSFER:

Be it resolved that the Section 15 Disciplining of Referenda Committees of the Electoral Code Policy be amended to read:
15.2 All other referenda committees:
a. The first offense will result in a warning
b. The second offense will result in the loss of fifty (50) percent of any possible re-imbursement
c. The third offense will result in the loss of approved campaign materials up to fifty (50) percent of the agreed upon flyers and posters
d. The forth offense will result in the with-holding of five (5) percent of votes favorable to the offending referenda campaign
e. The fifth offense will result in the with-holding of ten (10) percent of votes favorable to the offending referenda campaign
f. The sixth and final offense will result in the with-holding of one hundred (100) percent of the re-imbursement of funds spent campaigning and immediate disqualification.

MOVED: Erik Halliwell                 SECONDED: Abdirahman Hussein

Motion to update the Consolidated Electoral Code in Section 12.16 and Section 12.17

PRESENTATION SUMMARY:

Whereas there is no reason to prevent candidates from campaigning in what is the most active part of the University;
And whereas the CUSA Offices, Service Centers and Businesses should be impartial in the elections;
And whereas the Service Centers should be permitted to participate in referendums relevant to their purposes.

INFORMATION TRANSFER:

Be it resolved that Section 12.16 be amended to read:
12.16    Campaigning is not permitted in CUSA Offices, Businesses or Service Centers.
And be it resolved that Section 12.17 be stricken from the Electoral code and all subsequent sections be renumbered to reflect the change.
And be it resolved that Section 14.1j be amended to read:
14.1j.     Campaign in the University Center in the areas designated in Section 12.16.

MOVED: Brandon Wallingford            SECONDED:

Motion to Make All Important CUSA Announcements Put on CUSAonline.com

Whereas it is unreasonable for the Carleton University Students’ Association to assume that students regularly go to the CUSA office; and
Whereas students are not informed enough about activities going on in CUSA; and
Whereas we are in the 21st Century where the internet is a key element of university students’ lives; therefore

Information Transfer:

Be it further resolved that Carleton University Students’ Association put ALL announcements regarding dates for meetings, elections, referendums as well as other essential information for students on the CUSA website; and
Be it further resolved that the CUSA Executive ensures that the information on the website is correct and takes precedence over all other locations of the information;
MOVED: Brian Mason                SECONDED:

November Council Meeting – Important Agenda Items

There are four motions of interest:

1) Support the white ribbon campaign to end violence against women. It began as a way to urge men to speak out against violence against women.

2) Oppose the Canadian Blood Services lawsuit against Kyle Freeman, a gay man who gave blood. Gay men are excluded from the practice because they are deemed “high risk”.

3) Support the December 6th campaign, a national day of remembrance and action against violence against women for the anniversary of the Montreal massacre.

4) Motion CUSA to request CFS-Ontario’s acknowledgment and receipt of the petition submitted. It called for a referendum on Carleton’s continued membership in the Canadian Federation of Students.

If you have any last minute motions or points of interest you’d like me to raise – please let me know!

October Councilor Report:

Not much to report this month. CUSA will be adopting a minute of silence during Remembrance Day. Also, a motion to oppose the Univeristy’s steps to eliminate examination proctors was passed.

September Councilor Report:

We had our first CUSA Council meeting tonight for the Fall term. I spoke of Journalists for Human Rights “Speak Silence” on Oct. 6 which calls for 24 hours of silence in solidarity with journalists who cannot speak freely themselves. I also mentioned students will be in the Atrium and the Market from 11-3 taking donations to help send Canadian journalists to train African reporters to report on human rights abuses.

I raised concern over the outdated CUSA Council website and was assured they are in the process of updating the site.

And finally, the most heated debate of the night was over a motion with regards to the recent petitions circulating to withdraw from the Canadian Federation of Students. The motion wanted to mandate all CUSA Councillors to support continued membership in the CSA and be mandated to caompaign in support of membership in the CFS.

While I have been clear that I support the CFS and the importance of being in a national student union, I do not believe mandating councilor support is within the spirit of democracy. Therefore, I abstained.

The motion passed with 17 for, 9 against, and 7 abstentions.

As always, I am open to comment, debate, and discussion.

About:

The Carleton Universty Students’ Association is an incorporated, non-profit, student-run organization that promotes the interests of students. Every Carleton undergraduate student is a

cusa

member of CUSA and you are encouraged to take advantage of the services and advocacy the Association officers.

CUSA sponsors over 200 clubs and societies and runs a number of service centres to help students become active in their university. They also own and operate a number of businesses on campus and organizations student events.

CUSA isn’t just a social organization, they also provide a voice for students to the University administration, and to the local, provincial, and federal governments.

For more about CUSA and other services the Association provides, check out the tunnel boards, the website, or visit the office at 401 Unicentre.

Visit us Online

11 Responses

  1. Allie,

    As many people are probably unaware, a CUSA council meeting was held tonight (Sept. 29) during which a motion was passed that mandates each CUSA councillor not support holding a referendum on the issue of continuing membership in the Canadian Federation of Students.

    As an elected representative of journalism students, I’m asking you to account for your vote on this motion, explain your position, and also demonstrate how you gaged your journalism peers’ views on this issue. Because you are our representative, I think this is a fair request.

    Thanks,

    Dana Wagner

    • Hi Dana

      There was a motion passed at the CUSA Council meeting Tuesday night mandating that all CUSA Councilors support the Canadian Federation of Students.

      I decided to abstain. I have made it clear that I personally support the CFS and believe it is a very worthwhile organization for Carleton students to be members of. However, I do not believe that it is appropriate to force someone to adhere to a set of beliefs. Therefore, I did not support, nor did I oppose, the motion.

      With regards to how I engaged journalism students about this, or any other issue, I believe I am one of the most transparent councillors at Carleton. The website I run has updated information about important events, including the CUSA Council meeting. There is also a CUSA and About Me section with options to comment or send me a personal email. Furthermore I spoke about the issue in class, shared my personal position, and made it clear that I am open to discussion and debate.

      I hope that answers your questions.

      Cheers

      Allie

  2. Allie,

    Thanks for your quick response. I want to begin by saying I agree with you, you are very engaged with journalism students and you have opened up paths for communication with your peers more so than many other councillors.

    However, I think important CUSA council information is still either unavailable or not easily accessible. Have you considered posting the dates of upcoming CUSA meetings on this web site? Or beginning an online discussion of relevant issues prior to a meeting? Or posting the results of a meeting on this web site afterwards – like the text of the motion that was passed regarding the CFS?

    I am also unable to follow your reasoning for abstaining from the vote tonight. The reason you gave for abstaining is because you do not believe it is appropriate to force someone to adhere to a set of beliefs. This is opposition to the procedure the motion demands. Would it not then follow that you would have opposed such a motion, regardless of your personal support/opposition for the contextual issue at hand?

    Dana

    • Dana,

      All I can say is I’m working on it. As I’m sure you can imagine, managing this site, figuring out how to properly utilize it, as well as other obligations means this is a process of trial and error.

      As you’ll see on the Home Page, I’ve given an overview of my activities at the meeting, which include pressuring CUSA to update their Council website.

      I appreciate that you have taken it upon yourself to start a debate and I encourage students to use this as a forum, not a top-down directive.

      There will be more to come on the meeting and the motion in the next coming days.

      Cheers,

      Allie

  3. Hey folks,

    Naturally as the “other side” in the CFS debate, I feel like I should add in my two cents. I appreciate the fact that you abstained on moral grounds Allie. I am not at all surprised that a certain faction in CUSA thinks they have the authority to tell councilors and executives what causes to support. They insist that students speak with “one voice” despite the fact that students are obviously deeply divided on this issue.

    I would hope that as our journalism councilor you will insist that our executive be held accountable for their actions on this issue. They have already denied my request to hear how much money has already been spent on this campaign, but students have a right to know. If they continue to act in this way, I hope you will consider opposing future actions by this faction of CUSA until there is serious reform.

    After all, if we cannot reform CUSA, how can we hope to reform the CFS?

  4. Hi Allie!

    Thank you for using this blog, because it’s a great way to foster open dialogue between journalism students. The councilor report is a great idea and I’d really like if you could continue reporting on all the stuff that you do as journalism councilor, just to keep everybody informed about what’s going on.

    I was at the council meeting last night and I support your abstain in the voting process. I also appreciate and respect that you have personal views on many different issues and I think that’s an important quality in a person. Also thanks for bringing up the JHR speak silence campaign and shining light on the fact that the CUSA website isn’t updated as much as it could be.

    All that being said, there seems to be a whole lot of people on council working with very closed minds. One person at council tried to explain this whole CFS thing along the lines of: a long time ago, people voted to give money to CKCU and the Charlatan. We should trust what people decided for us a long time ago, and if there are students on campus that want to stop giving money to CKCU and the Charlatan, well that is bad and we shouldn’t even let them go any further or have a referendum about giving money to those groups.

    If that is the position that CUSA is taking regarding the CFS petition, I think it is really disturbing. Using the same CKCU and Charlatan analogy, I personally think that we should keep giving money to those groups, but if there is a large population of students that have organized a petition because they want to stop giving money to CKCU and the Charlatan, then they deserve to have a voice, whether or not I agree with what they are trying to do.

    Of course, this is not about those organizations; it’s about the Canadian Federation of Students. The people on council should recognize that there is a large group of students on campus that obviously have a problem. There are people who want out. They deserve a voice, and every student on campus needs to educate themselves about the issues. I see this ending very badly for everybody because I fear that it will turn into a very ugly, smear campaign of personal attacks. This is unfortunate because if there is a referendum, it will be the first time in over a decade that there is a chance for every student at Carleton to step up and make an informed decision about a huge organization on campus, and the worst thing that could happen is for the issues to get lost in a sea of hate campaigning.

    That’s about it. This is going to be a very big, ongoing issue at Carleton. I don’t want the school to once again feel as divided as it felt last year during the Shinerama debate or CUSA elections. I don’t feel optimistic about it because I just expect it to end up very bad for both parties, and consequently, every Carleton student in the middle of another power struggle.

    All the best,
    Maggie

  5. I seriously do not believe I have it in me to keep up with maintaining a site like it! Nice job, I seriously would like to see you keep up with it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.